skip to content

Faculty of Economics

Journal Cover

Lawson, T.

Mathematical modelling and ideology in the economics academy: competing explanations of the failings of the modern discipline?

Economic Thought: History, Philosophy, and Methodology

Vol. 1 no. 1 pp. 3-22 (2012)

Abstract: The widespread and long-lived failings of academic economics are due to an over-reliance on largely inappropriate mathematical methods of analysis. This is an assessment I have long maintained. Many heterodox economists, however, appear to hold instead that the central problem is a form of political-economic ideology. Specifically, it is widely contended in heterodox circles that the discipline goes astray just because so many economists are committed to a portrayal of the market economy as a smoothly or efficiently functioning system or some such, a portrayal that, whether sincerely held or otherwise, is inconsistent with the workings of social reality. Here I critically examine the contention that a form of political-economic ideology of this sort is the primary problem and assess its explanatory power. I conclude that the contention does not fare very well. I do not, though, deny that ideology of some sort has a major impact on the output of the modern economics academy. However it is of a different nature to the form typically discussed, and works in somewhat indirect and complex ways. Having raised the question of the impact of ideology I take the opportunity to explore its play in the economics academy more generally.

Author links: Tony Lawson  

Publisher's Link:

Papers and Publications

Recent Publications

Onatski, A. and Wang, C. Spurious Factor Analysis Econometrica, forthcoming [2020]

Bhattacharya, D. The Empirical Content of Binary Choice Models Econometrica [2020]

Aidt, T. S., Asatryan, Z., Badalyan, L. and Heinemann, F. Vote Buying or (Political) Business (Cycles) as Usual? Review of Economics and Statistics [2020]

Agranov, M. and Elliott, M. Commitment and (in) Efficiency: A Bargaining Experiment Journal of the European Economic Association [2020]