skip to content

Faculty of Economics

Journal Cover

Bhattacharya, D.

The Empirical Content of Binary Choice Models

Econometrica

Vol. 89 no. 1 pp. 457-474 (2021)

Abstract: An important goal of empirical demand analysis is choice and welfare prediction on counterfactual budget sets arising from potential policy-interventions. Such predictions are more credible when made without arbitrary functional-form/distributional assumptions, and instead based solely on economic rationality, i.e. that choice is consistent with utility maximization by a heterogeneous population. This paper investigates nonparametric economic rationality in the empirically important context of binary choice. We show that under general unobserved heterogeneity, economic rationality is equivalent to a pair of Slutsky-like shape-restrictions on choice-probability functions. The forms of these restrictions differ from Slutsky-inequalities for continuous goods. Unlike McFadden-Richter's stochastic revealed preference, our shape-restrictions (a) are global, i.e. their forms do not depend on which and how many budget-sets are observed, (b) are closed-form, hence easy to impose on parametric/semi/non-parametric models in practical applications, and (c) provide computationally simple, theory-consistent bounds on demand and welfare predictions on counterfactual budget-sets.

Keywords: Binary choice, general heterogeneity, income effect, utility maximization, integrability/rationalizability, Slutsky inequality, shape-restrictions

JEL Codes: C14, C25, D12

Author links: Debopam Bhattacharya  

Publisher's Link: https://doi.org/10.3982/ECTA16801



Papers and Publications



Recent Publications


Fruehwirth, J., Iyer, S. and Zhang, A. Religion and Depression in Adolescence Journal of Political Economy [2019]

Elliott, M. and Golub, B. A Network Approach to Public Goods Journal of Political Economy [2019]

Biroli, P., Boneva, T., Raja, A. and Rauh, C. Parental Beliefs About Returns to Child Health Investments Journal of Econometrics [2020]

Cavalcanti, T. and Santos, M. (Mis)Allocation Effects of an Overpaid Public Sector Journal of the European Economic Association [2020]