skip to content

Faculty of Economics

Journal Cover

Gudgin, G., Coutts, K., Gibson, N. and Buchanan, J.

Defying Gravity: A Critique of Estimates of the Economic Impact of Brexit

Policy Exchange


Abstract: The predictions of the Treasury, OECD and IMF for the long-term impact of Brexit remain influential. They provide an important context for the Brexit negotiations and underpin the belief of Scottish and Irish nationalists that Brexit strengthens their case for independence or Irish unity. Because these predictions have received limited scrutiny, they are examined in detail in this report.
The bases of the predictions are similar for each of the three organisations. In each case estimates are made of the impact of Brexit on trade and on foreign direct investment. This is followed by an estimate of the knock-on effect on productivity. The OECD and IMF also include an assessment of the impact of lower migration. The aggregate impact of these factors is then fed into a macro-economic model to obtain forecasts for GDP and unemployment.
Much of the final impact depends on the estimate for trade which, in each case, is assessed using a ‘gravity model’. Because gravity models are inaccessible to the general public, they are explained here in comprehensible terms. In addition the Treasury’s gravity model results are replicated and examined in detail. Our conclusion is that different versions of the model give a range of results. Most importantly the trade impacts reported by the Treasury and OECD are an average for all EU countries. We find that the specific impact for the UK is much smaller. The implication is that these official predictions of the impact of Brexit are overly pessimistic.

Author links: Ken Coutts  

Publisher's Link:

Papers and Publications

Recent Publications

Faraglia, E., Marcet, A., Oikonomou, R. and Scott, A. Government Debt management: the Short and the Long of it Review of Economic Studies [2019]

Galeotti, A., Golub, B. and Goyal, S. Targeting Interventions in Networks Econometrica [2020]

Agranov, M. and Elliott, M. Commitment and (in) Efficiency: A Bargaining Experiment Journal of the European Economic Association [2020]

Vogt, M., Linton, O. Multiscale clustering of nonparametric regression curves Journal of Econometrics [2020]